Green genetic engineering: A rethink is required
There are now more skeptics than ever before when it comes to biotechnological plant breeding methods, despite 30 years of research having produced a clear data basis. Conventional genetic engineering or the more modern CRISPR/Cas method present no increased risks compared to traditional breeding methods, such as cross-breeding. It is time to see new technologies as a way of fighting climate change and preventing environmental damage.
Monday, July 25, 2022
There are two key arguments that are made time and time again by genetic engineering critics. Firstly, they argue that genetically modified (GM) plants could be harmful to human health. Secondly, they repeatedly claim that such plants could have a negative impact on the surrounding ecosystems. However, the results of more than 30 years of research suggest otherwise on both counts. As Bloomberg’s Amanda Little writes, “no evidence has ever been found proving that GMOs harm human health”. The World Health Organization, the US National Academy of Sciences and many other large research institutions around the world have reached the same conclusion.
30 years of research verify safety
It is within the realms of possibility that GM plants start to grow in the wild and crossbreed with related wild species. Plants of this type were found in Mexico in 2001 and 2009. However, no evidence has been found that these plants have brought about negative ecological changes. Urs Niggli, a pioneer of organic products, draws similar conclusions in an article published in the “Der Pragmaticus” online magazine: “The data is clear: In principle, as regards their effect on (agro-)ecosystems and on human health, new breeding methods are indistinguishable from traditional cross-breeding.” According to Niggli, despite this solid data basis, there is a persistent skepticism toward genetic engineering: “30 years of scientific progress, countless studies taking into account society’s viewpoint, thousands of forums and debates, for which scientists take time out of their laboratories, and yet, more than half of the population are still convinced that we do not know enough to open ‘Pandora's Box.’”
Blindspot article
Pragmatic solutions not ideology
Green genetic engineering, in particular innovative genome editing, shows huge potential when it comes to breeding drought- and pest-resistant plants. If global agriculture is to sustain 10 billion people by 2050, it will have to be innovative. According to Niggli, this includes modern research methods, digitalization, molecular biology and material sciences (e.g. nanotechnologies for extending the shelf life of food products). Faced with a need for sustainable problem solving, Niggli considers it logical to use these technologies. As the title of the “Pragmaticus” article states: To guarantee food security and simultaneously protect the environment, we need pragmatic solutions, not ideology.
Related articles
"The EU is moving forward – Switzerland must not lose touch"
The EU has largely approved genomic plant breeding. Four plant researchers from the University of Zurich, ETH, and Agroscope contextualize the EU decision from June 17, 2026.
Neither Left nor Right: Forward!
In climate, energy, and agricultural policy, beliefs often take precedence over facts. The American think tank The Breakthrough Institute demonstrates a different approach: embracing disagreement, evaluating technologies with an open mind, and viewing productivity as an ally of environmental protection.
Why consumers accept gene-edited foods on their plates
Acceptance of gene-edited foods increases when their tangible benefits are clear to consumers. Studies show that visible advantages for health, the environment or food security are key to public support.
Condoms made from dandelions? Thanks to genome editing, it could become possible!
Bright yellow and widespread, dandelions shape our meadows. While some see them as troublesome weeds, researchers are discovering a sustainable industrial resource in the plant. Thanks to modern genome editing, the humble dandelion could soon provide rubber for condoms, gloves and tyres – right on our doorstep.