Vegetarian products have a bad reputation among consumers
Many consumers are of the opinion that vegetarian products are unhealthier and more harmful to the environment than meat. This is shown by a study by ETH Zurich. The negative attitude is also reflected in purchases. Vegetarian products are still niche products.
Friday, January 14, 2022
In 2020, more than 150 new vegetarian products came onto the Swiss market. However, their market share was just 2.3 percent. "foodaktuell" is reporting on the reasons for the reluctance of consumers. For example, researchers at the Institute for Environmental Decisions at ETH Zurich had more than 500 people rate protein-rich foods such as meat, cheese or meat substitutes. The results of the study are published in the specialist journal "Food Quality and Preference". According to the authors of the study led by Christina Hartmann, the participants rated meat substitutes as less environmentally friendly than meat. This is despite the fact that the products usually perform better than meat according to life cycle assessments.
Unnatural and unhealthy?
Respondents also do not consider meat substitutes to be healthier. They rated the nutritional profiles of animal products as more beneficial for health than tofu, falafel or ground soy - although the values are comparable. In addition, the perception of naturalness is different. Meat substitutes were considered less natural compared to meat, cheese or fish. According to Hartmann, there is a typical pattern: "Processed products, which are in fact less natural, are also thought to be less healthy. Although that doesn't necessarily have to be the case."
Use of labels doubtful
Hartmann is critical of labeling food using a traffic light system, such as the Nutri-Score. There is already an almost unmanageable number of labels, especially in the area of sustainability. The extension to health aspects could make shopping even more confusing: "It is doubtful that all consumers, across all levels of education, understand the labeling," Hartmann told "foodaktuell". People who are interested in the environment and health would find out more elsewhere. Even with a label, you wouldn't be able to get the uninterested interested in these topics. The study authors conclude: The negative consumer perception of meat substitutes remains a major challenge for industry, public health and more sustainable nutrition.
Sources
Price before (unclear) sustainability labels
The label confusion is confirmed in a representative survey by the Swiss Retail Federation, the association of retail companies, on the shopping behavior of Swiss consumers: More than a quarter of respondents say they recognize a label but don't know exactly what it stands for. Only for a quarter of those surveyed is the sustainability label of a product more important than its price. 38 percent stated that their purchase decision was a combination of label and price. 37 percent said that the price is more important to them than a sustainability label. It would be interesting to find out whether more transparency about the criteria for so-called sustainability labels influences purchasing behavior.
Related articles
Imports instead of regionality: tomato virus destroys domestic production
Although tomatoes and peppers are among the most popular vegetables in Switzerland, most of them are imported. Extreme weather conditions and diseases are to blame. The first companies have already developed resistant tomato varieties – but the federal government remains sceptical of new technologies.
Catastrophic wheat harvest: Bad weather and restrictions on crop protection
The reports are piling up: 2024 will go down in history as the worst wheat harvest in decades. One of Switzerland's largest grain collection centres in Thalheim an der Thur suffers a historic loss.
« The Bernese winegrowers spray and spray »
The heavy rainfall this summer has hit Bernese wine-makers hard and once again made it clear that crop protection is essential – especially in difficult growing years. The fact that fungal resistance also affects crop losses shows how precarious the situation is. Nevertheless, the federal government is hesitant when it comes to the authorisation of modern pesticides and new breeding technologies.
Why jellyfish could soon end up on our plates
Will jellyfish become the new star in the superfood sky? Experts recommend eating them and rave about the slippery sea creatures as a new source of protein. However, such products have yet to be authorised.