Opinions
Roman Mazzotta

Seizing the opportunity of green biotechnology

It's crucial for Switzerland to reestablish its leadership in biotechnology and actively contribute to addressing global concerns. Achieving this requires greater courage and openness to new technologies.

Monday, September 5, 2022

This guest commentary by Roman Mazzotta, Country President Syngenta Switzerland, was first published in the Neue Zürcher Zeitung on 21 August 2023.

The imminent challenge for the world is to ensure affordable food for an anticipated global population of nearly ten billion by 2050, all while safeguarding our climate and environment. Among the pivotal solutions is plant breeding, notably illustrated by the Nobel Prize-winning Crispr-Cas9 genetic scissors. This allows for the precise and swift enhancement of existing plant varieties without introducing foreign genes. As a result, we can develop crops that are more resistant to diseases and droughts.

The EU has highlighted the significance of these new breeding technologies for a more sustainable agriculture and announced its intentions to revise regulations surrounding them. This decision by the EU also profoundly influences Switzerland's political approach to these new technologies. Historically, Switzerland missed numerous opportunities in embracing plant biotechnology. In the early 2000s, it was at the forefront of modern plant breeding and agricultural genetic engineering. A notable breakthrough was the "Golden Rice" developed by ETH professor Ingo Potrykus. This innovation presented a potential solution to protect children in developing countries from the perils of vitamin A deficiency, including blindness and death. Unfortunately, several environmental and aid organizations continue to block its widespread adoption.

The private sector also strongly pursued plant breeding research during this period. However, a blanket moratorium on genetic engineering rendered Switzerland a less appealing research destination. This led to the migration of pioneering research to foreign soils. Today, outside of Agroscope's governmental breeding department, there is little expertise left in applied plant genetics. Due to this moratorium, Swiss farmers are deprived of the advancements of green genetic engineering. For instance, they are prohibited from cultivating a specific corn variety, developed using novel technologies, known to reduce methane emissions from cows. They are also barred from growing mildew-tolerant wheat.

While the public remains open to novel technologies when the advantages are evident, there are adversaries who strive to prolong a detrimental blockade policy by shifting the debate's focus. A rising point of criticism is the patenting of seeds. A prevalent misconception is that primarily large corporations stand to gain from these patents. Such a narrative is both one-sided and false. In reality, patents are the cornerstone of Switzerland's successful economic model. They safeguard the interests of the entire Swiss economic ecosystem, from individual inventors to SMEs competing globally. Current patent regulations are clear: Neither Switzerland nor the EU grants patents on plant varieties. Furthermore, in Europe, properties of a plant resulting from traditional breeding methods remain non-patentable.

Contrary to widespread belief, large corporations don't monopolize access to genetic resources and seeds. Companies like Syngenta have streamlined the process for small farmers to obtain protected seeds. Syngenta champions transparency by listing their plant patents in public databases and dedicated licensing platforms. This enables even the smallest plant breeders to examine Syngenta's patents related to specific plant varieties in Switzerland and potentially obtain a license.

The European Commission has recently brought forward a new law for new breeding technologies in agriculture. Meanwhile, there's an eager anticipation in Switzerland regarding the Federal Council's proposal on the matter. It's crucial for Switzerland to reestablish its leadership in biotechnology and actively contribute to addressing global concerns. Achieving this requires greater courage and openness to new technologies.

Kindly note:

We, a non-native editorial team value clear and faultless communication. At times we have to prioritize speed over perfection, utilizing tools, that are still learning.

We are deepL sorry for any observed stylistic or spelling errors.

Ernährung: Gehört der grünen Genschere die Zukunft?

Markus Hardegger

Markus Hardegger

Markus Hardegger ist Leiter Fachbereich Genetische Ressourcen, Produktionssicherheit und Futtermittel am Bundesamt für Landwirtschaft (BLW).

«Plant breeding calls for liberal rules»

Jürg Niklaus

Jürg Niklaus

Jürg Niklaus has a doctorate in law and is an advocate of plant breeding.

More pesticides, more genetic engineering: How we are overcoming hunger.

Markus Somm

Markus Somm

Journalist, publicist, publisher and historian

«The fear of genetically modified plants is unwarranted»

Anke Fossgreen

Anke Fossgreen

Head of Knowledge Team Tamedia

«Politicians must avoid pushing prices up even more»

Babette Sigg Frank

Babette Sigg Frank

President of the Swiss Consumer Forum (KF)

Seizing the opportunity of green biotechnology

Roman Mazzotta

Roman Mazzotta

Country President Syngenta Switzerland

«Sustainability means more»

Hendrik Varnholt

Hendrik Varnholt

Journalist at Lebensmittel Zeitung

«One-third organic farming does not solve the problem»

Olaf Deininger

Olaf Deininger

Development Editor-in-Chief Agrar-Medien

«Ecological methods alone won’t cut it»

Saori Dubourg

Saori Dubourg

“Ecological methods alone won’t cut it”

«Most fears about pesticides are misplaced»

Michelle Miller

Michelle Miller

Columnist at Genetic Literacy Project and AGDaily

Agriculture needs new technologies

Erik Fyrwald

Erik Fyrwald

CEO Syngenta Group

«Modern pesticides can help fight climate change»

Jon Parr

Jon Parr

President of Syngenta Crop Protection

«Who is afraid of the evil GMOs?»

Jürg Vollmer

Jürg Vollmer

Editor-in-Chief of «die grüne» magazine

Content in German

«What plant breeding brings us»

Achim Walter

Achim Walter

Professor of Crop Science, ETH Zurich

Content in German

«Research and work place needs impetus»

Jan Lucht

Jan Lucht

Head of Biotechnology at Scienceindustries

Content in German

«Agriculture plays a major role»

Jan Grenz

Jan Grenz

Lecturer in Sustainability, School of Agricultural, Forest and Food Sciences HAFL

«Understanding nature’s mechanisms better»

Urs Niggli

Urs Niggli

Agricultural scientist and president of Agroecology Science

«For food security, we need genuine Swiss production»

Jil Schuller

Jil Schuller

Editor «BauernZeitung»

«Lay people completely disregard the dose»

Michael Siegrist

Michael Siegrist

Professor of Consumer Behaviour, ETH Zurich

Content in German

«Is organic really healthier?»

Anna Bozzi

Anna Bozzi

Head of Nutrition and Agriculture at scienceindustries

Content in German

«Genetic engineering and environmental protection go hand in hand»

Dr. Teresa Koller

Dr. Teresa Koller

Researcher at the Institute of Plant and Microbiology at the University of Zurich

«The «Greta» generation will rigorously dispel paradigms.»

Bruno Studer

Bruno Studer

Professor for Molecular Plant Breeding, ETH Zurich

Content in German

«Overcoming the urban-rural divide with constructive agricultural policy»

Jürg Vollmer

Jürg Vollmer

Editor-in-Chief of «die grüne» magazine

Content in German

«We protect what we use»

Regina Ammann

Regina Ammann

Head of Business Sustainability, Syngenta Switzerland

Content in German

Related articles

Potato farmers want robust varieties
Media

Potato farmers want robust varieties

As the use of pesticides is to be massively reduced, the potato industry now wants to focus on more robust varieties. The industry has even concluded a target agreement with the federal government. This is ambitious: By 2040, robust varieties are to thrive on 80% of potato cultivation areas.

How genetic engineering is saving the Cavendish banana
Media

How genetic engineering is saving the Cavendish banana

The most popular banana variety - the so-called Cavendish banana - could soon disappear due to a persistent fungus. Australian researchers have developed a solution based on genetic engineering.

Nutrition: Does the future belong to the green gene scissors?
Knowledge

Nutrition: Does the future belong to the green gene scissors?

New plant varieties contribute to security of supply. The new breeding methods known as "gene scissors", such as Crispr, have the potential to revolutionise agriculture and nutrition.

Will this field trial revolutionise barley production?
Media

Will this field trial revolutionise barley production?

Switzerland's first field trial using plants from new breeding technologies will start this spring in Zurich. Specifically, the aim is to breed a spring barley that produces more grains per ear. If the trial works, the technology is likely to be of great interest to Swiss agriculture.