Opinions
David Brugger

We are bringing up the rear in Europe when it comes to plant protection

Plant protection products that have been approved in the EU should also be authorised in Switzerland as quickly as possible, writes guest author David Brugger from the Swiss Farmers' Union.

Thursday, January 23, 2025

They should be glowing yellow now – the rape fields. But instead of a rich yellow, there is a lot of green to be seen. The reason for this is the enormous infestation of the rape beetle. Despite two to three treatments with an insecticide, it can no longer be adequately controlled. To a large extent, the problem is homemade. In recent years, we in Switzerland have lost around a third of all active ingredients in plant protection products. Two-thirds of the insecticides used to control pests in oilseed rape have now been banned, without the authorities providing any effective alternatives. Seed dressing products have also been phased out.


The federal government realises that things can't go on like this.

One of the reasons for this is our completely gridlocked approval system for plant protection products. There are 770 products currently in the approval process, and the waiting time is also record-breaking. In some cases, it has been eight years already. After massive pressure, environmental organisations were granted a comprehensive right to a say in the matter a few years ago, the likes of which is not seen anywhere else in Europe. The consequences of this drastic remedy are now visible everywhere in the fields. There is a lack of solutions for combating wireworms, spotted wing drosophila and the cotton bollworm, which are destroying the harvests of entire cherry, bean and sweetcorn fields. But gaps in the use of herbicides are also causing problems. Problem grasses and weeds are continuing to spread. The federal government now realises that things cannot go on like this.

In an interim report on the implementation of the National Action Plan for Plant Protection, the Federal Office for Agriculture found that only two of the three main objectives were being achieved: protection of the environment and of humans. For the third objective, protection of crops, there was deterioration instead of improvement. The federal government is therefore proposing a revision of the Plant Protection Products Ordinance. However, the proposal does not in any way solve the urgent problems in practice. In principle, it only provides for an increase in the number of staff by 6 to 52 (!) full-time positions. The basic problem – the completely blocked and inefficient authorisation process – remains unsolved.


Damage to plant production in Switzerland

That is why we propose introducing the same procedure for plant protection as has been successfully practised for biocides for many years. In this area, Switzerland has always adopted the EU authorisation decisions – without anyone ever being upset about it or making unacceptable concessions to the environment. One third of all plant protection products are also authorised as biocides. If they are used as plant protection products, they are disadvantaged.

Until a few years ago, environmental organisations were full of praise for the EU authorisation process. Today, they want nothing more to do with it. Switzerland should ban everything immediately and without its own review if the EU does so. However, when new products come onto the market, they should continue to have to wait years for their authorisation in Switzerland. In the end, plant production in Switzerland will lose out – precisely the area that the authorities, parliament and environmental organisations would like to see promoted urgently.

David Brugger is head of plant production at the Swiss Farmers' Union. This article was first published in the «BauernZeitung» on 15 April 2024.

Kindly note:

We, a non-native editorial team value clear and faultless communication. At times we have to prioritize speed over perfection, utilizing tools, that are still learning.

We are deepL sorry for any observed stylistic or spelling errors.

Agriculture needs a shared vision

Dr. Christian Stockmar

Dr. Christian Stockmar

Chairman of the Austrian Crop Protection Association

'Pure hubris'

Patrick Dümmler

Patrick Dümmler

Head of Sustainability and Economic Policy at the Swiss Trade Association

We are bringing up the rear in Europe when it comes to plant protection

David Brugger

David Brugger

Head of Plant Production, Swiss Farmers’ Union

The orange elephants in the room

Jürg Vollmer

Jürg Vollmer

Agricultural journalist

Reorientation in «genetic engineering»

Raphael Bühlmann

Raphael Bühlmann

Agricultural and business economist FH.

Politics seems resistant to facts

Beat Keller

Beat Keller

Beat Keller ist Professor für Molekulare Pflanzenbiologie an der Universität Zürich

«Plant breeding calls for liberal rules»

Jürg Niklaus

Jürg Niklaus

Jürg Niklaus has a doctorate in law and is an advocate of plant breeding.

More pesticides, more genetic engineering: How we are overcoming hunger.

Markus Somm

Markus Somm

Journalist, publicist, publisher and historian

«The fear of genetically modified plants is unwarranted»

Anke Fossgreen

Anke Fossgreen

Head of Knowledge Team Tamedia

«Politicians must avoid pushing prices up even more»

Babette Sigg Frank

Babette Sigg Frank

President of the Swiss Consumer Forum (KF)

Seizing the opportunity of green biotechnology

Roman Mazzotta

Roman Mazzotta

Country President Syngenta Switzerland

«Sustainability means more»

Hendrik Varnholt

Hendrik Varnholt

Journalist at Lebensmittel Zeitung

«One-third organic farming does not solve the problem»

Olaf Deininger

Olaf Deininger

Development Editor-in-Chief Agrar-Medien

«Ecological methods alone won’t cut it»

Saori Dubourg

Saori Dubourg

“Ecological methods alone won’t cut it”

«Most fears about pesticides are misplaced»

Michelle Miller

Michelle Miller

Columnist at Genetic Literacy Project and AGDaily

Agriculture needs new technologies

Erik Fyrwald

Erik Fyrwald

CEO Syngenta Group

«Modern pesticides can help fight climate change»

Jon Parr

Jon Parr

President of Syngenta Crop Protection

«Who is afraid of the evil GMOs?»

Jürg Vollmer

Jürg Vollmer

Editor-in-Chief of «die grüne» magazine

Content in German

«What plant breeding brings us»

Achim Walter

Achim Walter

Professor of Crop Science, ETH Zurich

Content in German

«Research and work place needs impetus»

Jan Lucht

Jan Lucht

Head of Biotechnology at Scienceindustries

Content in German

«Agriculture plays a major role»

Jan Grenz

Jan Grenz

Lecturer in Sustainability, School of Agricultural, Forest and Food Sciences HAFL

«Understanding nature’s mechanisms better»

Urs Niggli

Urs Niggli

Agricultural scientist and president of Agroecology Science

«For food security, we need genuine Swiss production»

Jil Schuller

Jil Schuller

Editor «BauernZeitung»

«Lay people completely disregard the dose»

Michael Siegrist

Michael Siegrist

Professor of Consumer Behaviour, ETH Zurich

Content in German

«Is organic really healthier?»

Anna Bozzi

Anna Bozzi

Head of Nutrition and Agriculture at scienceindustries

Content in German

«Genetic engineering and environmental protection go hand in hand»

Dr. Teresa Koller

Dr. Teresa Koller

Researcher at the Institute of Plant and Microbiology at the University of Zurich

«The «Greta» generation will rigorously dispel paradigms.»

Bruno Studer

Bruno Studer

Professor for Molecular Plant Breeding, ETH Zurich

Content in German

«Overcoming the urban-rural divide with constructive agricultural policy»

Jürg Vollmer

Jürg Vollmer

Editor-in-Chief of «die grüne» magazine

Content in German

«We protect what we use»

Regina Ammann

Regina Ammann

Head of Sustainability & Public Affairs, Syngenta Switzerland

Related articles

Tradition and innovation go hand in hand when it comes to food
Knowledge

Tradition and innovation go hand in hand when it comes to food

The study ‘Decoding Food Culture’ by the Gottlieb Duttweiler Institute shows how deeply food culture shapes our lives. That is why it is a balancing act between tradition and innovation to bring about changes in nutrition.

Genetic engineering in agriculture – where is Rösti's openness to technology?
Media

Genetic engineering in agriculture – where is Rösti's openness to technology?

Genetic engineering in agriculture – where is Rösti's openness to technology?

ESG reporting: little has been achieved apart from expenses
Media

ESG reporting: little has been achieved apart from expenses

The ESG criteria (Environmental, Social, Governance) are intended to guide companies towards sustainable action and transparency. Companies have to invest considerable resources in complying with regulations and preparing reports. The workload is constantly increasing. For many companies, these requirements are an enormous bureaucratic burden – with little or no benefit for actual sustainability.

The underestimated danger of plant toxins
Knowledge

The underestimated danger of plant toxins

Plants produce a variety of chemical substances to protect themselves against predators and diseases, for example. These substances can have a toxic effect in high doses. A recent study by Agroscope highlights the danger of natural substances in Swiss waters.