"Organic products do not require pesticides."
The fact that organic farmers work without pesticides is a commonly-held view, but it is clearly wrong. Around 60 percent of the Swiss top ten crop protection products are also approved for organic farming. The organic farming industry, in its current form, could not exist without modern synthetic plant protection products.
Friday, November 1, 2019
In brief
- Pesticides can be used as plant protection products in the field or as biocides in storage.
- More than 40 percent of the plant protection products sold in Switzerland are also approved for organic farming.
- An organic farming industry like that currently operated in Switzerland could not exist without modern, synthetic plant protection products.
Pesticides are any substance made of chemical or biological ingredients intended to prevent, destroy or combat diseases such as fungi or pests. Pesticides can be used as plant protection products in the field or as biocides in storage, transport or food processing. Such products may also be used in the organic farming sector, with restrictions. And they often are. In particular, special crops such as fruit, vines, vegetables and potatoes cannot be produced without substantial use of plant protection products, even in organic farming. And stable hygiene or safe food processing is not possible without biocides, even in bioproduction.
An organic farming industry like that currently operated in Switzerland could not exist without modern, synthetic plant protection products. The pesticides used in the organic farming industry are not inherently harmless either. For example, copper – a product without which fungal infestation in organic farming could hardly be fought – accumulates in the soil and is harmful to organisms living in soil and water. And there are also insecticides approved for organic farming, which are dangerous for bees. A ban on high-risk substances would also affect organic farming. This is confirmed by a study by Agroscope. Whether organic or conventional: When used in accordance with regulations, modern plant protection products are safe for humans, animals and the environment.
Blindspot article
Biopesticides catch up
More than 40 percent of the plant protection products sold in Switzerland are also approved for organic farming. According to the 2019 sales statistics of plant protection products in Switzerland, the trend is clearly rising. Among the five best-selling crop protection products in 2019, sulfur and paraffin oil were the top products – both are also used in the organic farming sector. Six out of the ten best-selling pesticides are allowed to be used by organic farmers.
Organic also relies on "synthetic"
Synthetically manufactured products are also used in bioproduction. These offer manyadvantages over other manufacturing processes, as explained here. For example, none of the copper salts popular in organic farming are extracted directly from nature, instead they are produced synthetically. Sulfur and paraffin oil are also two synthetic substances produced from petroleum derivatives. And many bio-crop protection products or biocides contain synthetic auxiliary substances and additives. In addition, additional plant protection products are recurrently allowed temporarily in organic farming in case of acute risk situations, in order to ensure effective protection of the harvests. In the summer heat wave in 2018, the use of the active ingredients azadirachtin and spinosad in organic farming was authorized, because otherwise the potato beetle would have eaten away the crops. You can see how the potato beetle behaves if it is not prevented by crop protection products in this informative video.
Related articles
Residues, thresholds, trust – looking calmly behind the headlines
In this conversation with toxicologist Lothar Aicher, the discussion focuses on how residues enter the body, how their potential harm is assessed, and what role modern analytical methods play.
Hazard is not the same as risk: how we understand – and should understand – threshold values
In this episode of the podcast, risk researcher Angela Bearth discusses residues and threshold values in food – a topic often debated emotionally. In public discussions, threshold values tend to dominate, while the complex challenges of agriculture are rarely considered. Studies show, however, that once these relationships are explained and solutions are addressed, people respond in a more differentiated way.
PFAS, trade-offs and responsibility – how politics and agriculture find solutions
In this episode of the joint series by Agrarpolitik – der Podcast and swiss-food.ch, National Councillor Christine Badertscher discusses how residues and threshold values are debated in Parliament.
Thresholds, approvals, responsibility – how plant protection products are really assessed
Threshold values are often at the centre of public debate – yet in reality they are only a small part of a much broader risk assessment system. Dr Michael Beer, Head of the Food and Nutrition Division at the Federal Food Safety Office, provides clarity.