Eastern Switzerland's Wine Harvest: It is not possible without plant health protection

Eastern Switzerland's Wine Harvest: It is not possible without plant health protection

The summer of 2021 will probably remain in the memory of the Eastern Swiss winemakers for a long time to come. The wet cold weather with hail storms causes major crop failures. The mildew, which could spread easily due to the moisture, is an additional aggravating factor. The financial damage is also serious.

Wednesday, September 15, 2021

As the "St. Galler Tagblatt" reports, 206 hail insurance claims have been reported in the regions of Zurich, Thurgau and Schaffhausen this year. Of 13,000 hectares, around 320 are affected. But the numbers are likely to be much higher. Where the hail is not responsible for the crop failures, the culprit is mildew. The fungal disease spreads especially in wet conditions and spreads a white layer over the vines until the grapes finally dry out. The frosty spring was followed by an exceptionally wet May. Many winemakers treated their vines too late with pesticides.


Difficult fight against mildew

The fight against the mildew was particularly difficult for the winegrowers this summer. In many places, the soil was so soaked and softened that tractors could not be used for the application of fungicides. A further bitter pill for the winegrowers to swallow was the fact that damages caused by mildew and other plant diseases cannot be insured. Although the effect of plant protection products wears off in heavy rain, they cannot be applied without spraying, says Christian Roth, president of the Schaffhauser Wein trade association.


New crop protection products blocked

But there is another problem that could get worse in the future. New plant protection products are hardly reaching the market at the moment because they are blocked by environmental associations: "Over 100 active substances for plant protection products are blocked. This makes it difficult to be innovative," says Stefan Odermatt of Syngenta in the "St. Galler Tagblatt". For example, the resources available to winegrowers are threatening to become increasingly scarce. Nevertheless, the Eastern Swiss wine farmers have not yet completely abandoned hope. With a golden autumn, there could still be a small but decent wine harvest.

Blockade on the approval of new plant protection products

The Swiss authorization system for plant protection products is blocked. This is not just a problem for the research industry, because new crop protection products are often safer and more environmentally friendly than older products. It is a major problem for Swiss farmers in particular, because they have available to them increasingly fewer different active substances due to the withdrawal or prohibition of plant protection products. However, if the same active ingredient is always used, resistance is rapidly developed – the pest or disease becomes immune. We know what that means from the discussion about antibiotic resistance.

Blindspot article

Large-scale sustainable food production and healthy eating are complex topics. They need to be viewed from different perspectives. Yet unpopular facts are all too often given short shrift in the public discussion. We illuminate the topics that usually remain in the shadows. This makes it possible for people with conflicting views to engage in a dialogue.

Related articles

Triazole in Lake Geneva: Authorities give the all-clear
Media

Triazole in Lake Geneva: Authorities give the all-clear

In late summer 2025, the news caused a stir: the substance 1,2,4-triazole – a chemical compound used in a wide variety of applications – was found in drinking water from Lake Geneva. Now the cantons of Geneva, Vaud and Valais have given the all-clear: the water is safe to drink.

'There is also a life before death' – Wine Pope Philipp Schwander on the Zeitgeist and the Activism of Health Authorities
Media

'There is also a life before death' – Wine Pope Philipp Schwander on the Zeitgeist and the Activism of Health Authorities

The Swiss Master of Wine criticizes in an interview that wine is increasingly being demonized – contrary to scientific evidence and without any discussion about dosage and risk.

Sushi from Swiss Rice – Possible for a Few Years Now
Media

Sushi from Swiss Rice – Possible for a Few Years Now

Where once lamb’s lettuce and potatoes grew, a crop more commonly associated with Asia is now thriving: rice. What might sound like an exotic experiment has in some parts of Switzerland developed into a promising niche with a future.

Ant infestation threatens Zurich communities
Media

Ant infestation threatens Zurich communities

An invasive ant from the Mediterranean region is spreading rapidly in the canton of Zurich, threatening communities, construction projects, and agriculture. Insecticides could help—but their use remains severely restricted.

More contributions from Media