"Pesticides are to blame for insect deaths."
Pesticides are repeatedly blamed for the decline in insects. That is too simplistic an assessment. The reality is much more complex. For example, overdevelopment has a much stronger influence on insect populations. This is demonstrated by a meta-study on global insect decline.
Saturday, November 2, 2019
In brief:
- The decline in insects is less severe than originally thought. While land insects have fallen by 9 percent per decade, water insects have increased by an average of 11 percent over the same period.
- It is also clear that various causes are responsible for the decline in the population of land insects.
- Lack of living spaces (e.g. due to lack of open spaces and or hedges); surface sealing of all kinds (e.g. through superstructures and roads); introduction of substances into the environment (for cleaning and plant protection); increase of light sources (e.g. through permanent lighting of roads); increase of traffic (collisions with insects); lack of protection of biotopes (fewer wetlands).
Honey bees, wild bees and other pollinators play a central role in agricultural ecosystems. Pollination by pollinators can contribute to improving agricultural yields. According to the Swiss Federal Statistical Office's Environment 2020 pocket statistics (p. 14), in 2018 around 42 000 hectares of cultivated land benefited from pollination by animals. This is about ten hectares more than 20 years ago. Pollinators promote production, especially in fruit or berries, but also in rapeseed or sunflowers.
There is no doubt that the improper use of plant protection products can be dangerous for humans, animals and the environment. But to make pesticides responsible for all insect deaths is far too simplistic. Several other important factors have been identified by science, which in some cases pose a significant threat to biodiversity. A comprehensive meta-study shows that the reasons for the decline of insects on land certainly have more than one cause.
Progressive overdevelopment as a problem
The study also shows: In fact, there is an increase of eleven percent in water insects. In our latitudes, the demand for land in favor of settlements and roads should play an important role. Colonization in Switzerland as well as in the whole of Europe is progressing rapidly. Besides the fragmentation of the landscape, the sealing of soils is the main problem. The latest figures from the pocket statistics for the Environment 2020 of the Federal Statistical Office (p. 31) show that the sealed areas have increased by 29 percent within 24 years. This means that almost 5 percent of the land area is sealed. The soils can then no longer fulfill their important functions for nutrient and water circulation. In addition, the light pollution associated with the colonization poses a threat to many insect species. The area of settlement continues to expand continuously, by more than 30 percent since just 1982. At the same time, farmland and meadows disappear.
Blindspot article
More and more bee colonies in Europe
Modern agriculture can also have a positive effect on insect diversity. For example, a study from the USA shows that honey bees are doing better in areas that are intensively used for agriculture, even if plant protection products are used there. This is due to the fact that agricultural areas offer a rich food supply and thus a good basis for living. In this way, endangered species can certainly benefit from agriculture. Contrary to all claims, according to FAO figures, the number of hives in Europe too has been increasing for years. A recent compilation shows that the decline of honey bees is a myth.
Related articles
Residues, thresholds, trust – looking calmly behind the headlines
In this conversation with toxicologist Lothar Aicher, the discussion focuses on how residues enter the body, how their potential harm is assessed, and what role modern analytical methods play.
Hazard is not the same as risk: how we understand – and should understand – threshold values
In this episode of the podcast, risk researcher Angela Bearth discusses residues and threshold values in food – a topic often debated emotionally. In public discussions, threshold values tend to dominate, while the complex challenges of agriculture are rarely considered. Studies show, however, that once these relationships are explained and solutions are addressed, people respond in a more differentiated way.
PFAS, trade-offs and responsibility – how politics and agriculture find solutions
In this episode of the joint series by Agrarpolitik – der Podcast and swiss-food.ch, National Councillor Christine Badertscher discusses how residues and threshold values are debated in Parliament.
Thresholds, approvals, responsibility – how plant protection products are really assessed
Threshold values are often at the centre of public debate – yet in reality they are only a small part of a much broader risk assessment system. Dr Michael Beer, Head of the Food and Nutrition Division at the Federal Food Safety Office, provides clarity.