The EU's Misguided Ban on Coffee Capsules
The EU is contemplating a ban on coffee capsules, with a draft legislation already put forward by the EU Commission. Should this law pass, only compostable coffee capsules would be permitted. While this move initially seems like a positive step against packaging waste, a closer look reveals it might not be beneficial for the environment. As highlighted by "NZZ", coffee capsules actually boast a more environmentally friendly footprint compared to other coffee preparation methods. This scenario underscores the importance of a holistic approach to environmental protection.
Friday, May 26, 2023
Switzerland stands out in global rankings, with its residents consuming an impressive 1,100 cups of coffee per person annually. While precise figures aren't available, a significant number of these cups probably come from plastic or aluminum capsules. Despite their popularity, these capsules have garnered criticism for their environmental impact, primarily because many end up as waste. Citing this, the "Neue Zürcher Zeitung" notes the EU's intention to prohibit these capsules. The proposed EU legislation would only permit compostable capsule systems in the future. This begs the question: Are coffee capsules truly as environmentally detrimental as widely believed?
Coffee capsules: Not As Bad As Perceived
Contrary to popular belief, "Neue Zürcher Zeitung" references multiple studies indicating that coffee capsules, whether made of aluminum or plastic, may have a comparable or even lower environmental impact than other coffee-making methods. For instance, research from the University of Quebec suggests that coffee from capsules is more eco-friendly than alternatives like filter or press coffee. This is attributed to the precise amount of coffee and energy used for each cup. Capsule systems use an exact amount of coffee and heat only the necessary water for a single cup, ensuring minimal waste.
It's Not Just About the Packaging
Echoing these findings, a Swiss study comparing the environmental impact of various coffee preparation methods - including automatic machines, coffee capsules, filter coffee, and moka pots - revealed that capsules might not be the villains they're made out to be. Throughout the entire lifecycle of coffee, capsules were found to be just as eco-friendly as filter coffee. In contrast, fully automatic machines had the most significant environmental impact, emitting around 30% more greenhouse gases than capsules. While packaging does contribute to a product's environmental footprint, its impact is overshadowed by factors like cultivation and preparation methods. Even though capsule packaging comprises about 15% of its environmental impact, the benefits of reduced coffee wastage and efficient machines balance it out.
A Broader Perspective on Sustainability
The widely held belief that coffee capsules are major environmental culprits is somewhat misplaced. By aiming to ban them, the EU might be taking a step backward. While the idea of switching to compostable capsules sounds good, its feasibility is uncertain. Plus, countries like Germany would need to develop new recycling infrastructures, as compostable capsules currently aren't allowed in their organic waste bins. This situation serves as a reminder that true sustainability requires considering multiple angles. Such comprehensive thinking should shape long-term policy decisions, rather than hasty bans lacking robust scientific backing. This lesson is applicable not just to coffee capsules but to broader issues like agriculture.
"Compostable" - but not necessarily suitable for home compost heaps
Many homeowners tend to their compost heaps, using home compost made from household waste as valuable fertilizer, and even growing pumpkins, for example, on these heaps. However, not everything labeled as "compostable" is necessarily suitable for home compost heaps. SRF is taking advantage of the EU directive to investigate the compostability of coffee capsules, as many of them do not decompose. This issue also applies to industrial composting plants. Consequently, it is anticipated that there will be disposal strategies developed for all types of coffee capsules.
Kindly note:
We, a non-native editorial team value clear and faultless communication. At times we have to prioritize speed over perfection, utilizing tools, that are still learning.
We are deepL sorry for any observed stylistic or spelling errors.
Related articles
Genetic scissors for the future – soon in Switzerland too?
Genome editing is seen as a promising way to make agriculture more sustainable and climate-resilient. But Switzerland is hesitant to approve it. A popular initiative even wants to ban it. But what can CRISPR really do?
Less than 50 percent: How Switzerland is squandering its self-sufficiency
Swiss agriculture is under enormous pressure. Extreme weather conditions, pests and increasingly stringent regulations are putting producers under strain. As a result, self-sufficiency is falling dramatically, especially for plant-based foods. To ensure food security in Switzerland, effective plant protection products are urgently needed.
Only half the truth in the genetic engineering debate
Those who only see the risks remain blind to the opportunities offered by a new technology. Opponents of genetic engineering have presented a new survey on new breeding methods, which reveals some telling gaps.
«The FOAG is abandoning productive agriculture»
Increasing pests, missing tools, growing bureaucracy – the farmers' criticism of the federal government is loud and clear. Swiss agriculture is at its limit, reports Blick. The demand: effective plant protection products are urgently needed again.